A ring should slide on with a slight push over the knuckle, sit without pinching, and take a little resistance to remove (Jewelers Mutual). One size is about 2.5 mm, so small differences are noticeable.
What one step means in millimeters
A whole US size is about 2.5 mm of circumference and a half size about 1.3 mm. That is the scale of every adjustment discussed on this page: a bead that gives roughly half a size (Jewelers Mutual) changes the inside circumference by about 1.3 mm, while a two-size change is about 5.1 mm.
US size
Diameter (mm)
Circumference (mm)
5
15.70
49.3
6
16.51
51.9
7
17.32
54.4
8
18.14
57.0
9
18.95
59.5
Calculated from the US definition (diameter in inches = 0.458 + 0.032 × size).
Seven-point check
It passes the knuckle with slight resistance, not force.
It does not spin freely when your hand hangs down.
There is no bulge (“muffin top”) of skin on either side.
No indentation lasting long after removal, no pain or tingling.
It does not slide off when you wash your hands or tilt your hand.
It still feels right at the end of the day and in warm weather.
On a wide band, it does not feel tight in the evening; wide bands usually need more room (GIA, David Yurman).
Signs it's wrong
Too small
Too big
Cannot rotate the ring
Spins on the finger
Skin muffin top
Stone turns sideways
Pain, tingling, indentation
Slides off
Signs listed by Jewelers Mutual.
When to test
Heat, humidity, exercise, salty food and alcohol enlarge fingers and cold shrinks them (Jewelers Mutual, GIA). Test at least twice, at different times of day, before concluding the size is wrong.
Worked example
Suppose a ring passes the knuckle only with force but spins at rest on a cold day. A hypothetical reading: the knuckle is larger than the base, so measure both and, as David Yurman suggests, choose a size in between. A knuckle at US 8 (57.0 mm) and a base at US 6 (51.9 mm) points to US 7 (54.4 mm).
Limits and honest caveats
The sources cited here are general jeweler guidance, not a test of any particular ring. Cost, method and risk depend on the setting, metal and width, so ask a jeweler to inspect the ring before any work. This site does not publish prices because none of the sources give figures we can verify, and the worked examples are hypothetical illustrations of the arithmetic, not reports of real customers.
Size values on this page are calculated with the Ring Size Tools conversion engine from the published definitions listed on the methodology page. Fit advice is attributed to the sources above.